Aspects of Scientific Practice/Organization Drift 27, Rm. 032 Organized Session
24 Jul 2019 04:00 PM - 06:00 PM(Europe/Amsterdam)
20190724T1600 20190724T1800 Europe/Amsterdam History of Conferences

From about the turn of the twentieth century, international conferences have become standard features of scientific life. Yet although they have frequently featured in the historiography, the role of such meetings has predominantly been discussed as a background against which the real action of interest took place. In this session we want to break with this tradition and put the spotlight fully on the conference itself, as a phenomenon. What were international scientific conferences? What kinds of interaction, sociability, and performance did they embody? What was their role in the production of knowledge? How did they mediate participants from different nations, ranks, classes, genders? How have their forms evolved and varied over time? These are many large questions and we do not pretend to answer them all. Instead, we hope to make a start by considering a number of angles from which conferences can be studied: their international character, their inclusivity and exclusivity, and the rituals that have accompanied them as gatherings of expert communities. Together we hope that these may indicate directions toward a fuller understanding of the phenomenon we are so familiar with.

Organized by Geert Somsen

Drift 27, Rm. 032 History of Science Society 2019 meeting@hssonline.org
33 attendees saved this session

From about the turn of the twentieth century, international conferences have become standard features of scientific life. Yet although they have frequently featured in the historiography, the role of such meetings has predominantly been discussed as a background against which the real action of interest took place. In this session we want to break with this tradition and put the spotlight fully on the conference itself, as a phenomenon. What were international scientific conferences? What kinds of interaction, sociability, and performance did they embody? What was their role in the production of knowledge? How did they mediate participants from different nations, ranks, classes, genders? How have their forms evolved and varied over time? These are many large questions and we do not pretend to answer them all. Instead, we hope to make a start by considering a number of angles from which conferences can be studied: their international character, their inclusivity and exclusivity, and the rituals that have accompanied them as gatherings of expert communities. Together we hope that these may indicate directions toward a fuller understanding of the phenomenon we are so familiar with.

Organized by Geert Somsen

Laboratories of Cooperation: UNRRA’s ConferencesView Abstract
Organized SessionAspects of Scientific Practice/Organization 04:00 PM - 04:30 PM (Europe/Amsterdam) 2019/07/24 14:00:00 UTC - 2019/07/24 14:30:00 UTC
In this paper I will consider the format and purposes of the conferences organised by the biggest and most impactful international organisation created during the Second World War: the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration (UNRRA). UNRRA’s many conferences, ranging from small meetings with scientific advisers to big diplomatic gatherings that debated and ratified UNRRA’s policy, provide plenty of reasons why historians of science should pay more attention to the history of conferences. Conferences in all their variety have a long history as meetings of informed minds with the aims to recalibrate terms, solve problems, achieve professional coherence and define who is a member of the club. UNRRA, as a formally ‘technical’ organisation, adapted the format of scientific conferences to solve intractable political problems, while at the same time drawing on older ideas about political congresses to create and steer technical consensus. One of the purposes of this paper therefore will be to point to the dual traffic of ideas and influences, between the political and scientific realms, shaping the mid-20th century conferences of international organisations such as UNRRA.
Presenters
JR
Jessica Reinisch
Birkbeck College, University Of London
Meet the Elite: Nobel Symposia and Scientific ExclusivityView Abstract
Organized SessionAspects of Scientific Practice/Organization 04:30 PM - 05:00 PM (Europe/Amsterdam) 2019/07/24 14:30:00 UTC - 2019/07/24 15:00:00 UTC
In the postwar era scientific conferences became ubiquitous and increasingly very large. As a reaction to this development, the Nobel Foundation in 1965 instituted the self-consciously elitist Nobel Symposia, still a going concern with around 160 meetings organized so far. The areas covered by the Nobel Symposia have mainly been those represented by the Nobel Prizes, including the prize in economic science founded in 1969. But issues of broader intellectual and social significance have sometimes been in focus as well. Using a frontstage-backstage approach this paper will examine the origins of the symposia – how they were conceived from a scientific as well as a political perspective, how support for the project was established nationally and internationally, and how the first symposia were organized and staged. A central question is that of exclusivity, how the symposia were imagined and staged as platforms for elite science and as a breeding ground for future elites. Particular attention will be paid to the 1969 symposium on “The place of values in a world of facts” which constituted the first but not the last example of how the symposia were used to stage more broadly conceived elite summits grappling with issues seen as important from the perspective of global development.
Presenters
SW
Sven Widmalm
Dept For History Of Science And Ideas, Uppsala University
Chemical Bonding: Ritual and Community-Formation at Chemistry Conferences, 1921-22View Abstract
Organized SessionAspects of Scientific Practice/Organization 05:00 PM - 05:30 PM (Europe/Amsterdam) 2019/07/24 15:00:00 UTC - 2019/07/24 15:30:00 UTC
In 1921 and 1922 the Utrecht-based chemist Ernst Cohen organized two informal international conferences. Their aim was to break the boycott of scientists from the former Central Powers that was the official policy of the new international scientific organizations established in the wake of the First World War. Like many scientists from formerly neutral countries, Cohen rejected that policy and tried to reunite his German and Austrian colleagues with their French, Belgian, British, Russian, and American counterparts. The two Utrecht meetings were meant as an “experiment” at such reintegration. In this paper I examine not so much the success of this attempt, but primarily how it was done. By what means did Cohen et al. try to re-establish a broken community? Precisely because this was the only objective of the two meetings, and their subject-matter was relatively unimportant, they offer a window on the mechanisms of community-formation at conferences. What was articulated, for example, at the speeches and toasts? What was the function of the excursions and banquets with courses named after famous chemists? What was the role of spouses in the meetings? And what was the meaning of the various papers, on subjects like “free radicals” and “bonding through light”, for the social aims of the conferences? These rituals have to be situated not only against the background of the war and its rifts, but also in the light of an elite culture of academic scientists faced with their increasingly important, and problematic, industrial connections.
Presenters
GS
Geert Somsen
Maastricht University
Commentary: History of ConferencesView Abstract
Organized Session 05:30 PM - 06:00 PM (Europe/Amsterdam) 2019/07/24 15:30:00 UTC - 2019/07/24 16:00:00 UTC
Presenters
GS
Geert Somsen
Maastricht University
Birkbeck College, University of London
Dept for History of Science and Ideas, Uppsala University
Maastricht University
University of Exeter
Adam Matthew Digital
University College London (UCL), UK
Ms. Emma Mojet
PhD Candidate, Vossius Center for the History of the Humanities and Sciences, University of Amsterdam
Dr. Roberto Lalli
Max Planck Institute for the History of Science, Berlin
Dr. Tim Boon
Science Museum Group
Upcoming Sessions
239 visits