Cranial Compatibility: Phrenology, Measurement, and Marriage Assessment

This abstract has open access
Abstract Summary
This paper demonstrates how phrenological tools of character assessment were used to measure marriage compatibility in the nineteenth century. It will examine how the knowledge and practices of cranial measurement produced character “profiles" for the purpose of judging suitable marriage partners. A popular but contested science of the mind, phrenology articulated a relationship between the mental and the physical, and maintained that one could truly know others and oneself through measuring “organs” of the mind, or protrusions on the skull. While much has been written about phrenology, less attention has been paid to its focus on marriage, mating and motherhood, and how its epistemic practices supported a model of courtship based on numerical and empirical assessment of gendered and racialized character traits. Focused on the North American context, this paper will use phrenological materials -- advice literature, personalized charts, photographs, mail order submissions and testimonials -- to illustrate how phrenology packaged cranial knowledge, promoting it as superior to other forms of matching. Many “practical” phrenologists claimed expertise on marital harmony, and sold their analyses as more accurate and reliable than personal experience or familial knowledge. Many consumers pursued this knowledge, hoping to find a partner with compatible crania, but more often to assess themselves and the fitness of a current suitor or spouse. Ultimately, this paper will show that notions of race and gender, heredity, and sexual “relations" were embedded in the shorthand of phrenological measurements.
Abstract ID :
HSS277
Submission Type
Abstract Topics
Chronological Classification :
19th century
Self-Designated Keywords :
gender & sexuality, ethnicity & race, instruments & measurements, phrenology, 19th century, social science, technology, medicine
Loyola Marymount University

Abstracts With Same Type

Abstract ID
Abstract Title
Abstract Topic
Submission Type
Primary Author
HSS575
Aspects of Scientific Practice/Organization
Organized Session
Prof. Anna Graber
HSS355
Technology
Organized Session
Francesco Cassata
HSS587
Medicine and Health
Organized Session
Chantal Marazia
HSS872
Thematic Approaches to the Study of Science
Organized Session
Dr. Alison Kraft
HSS5847
Biology
Organized Session
Dr. Dominik Huenniger
HSS512
Aspects of Scientific Practice/Organization
Organized Session
Alrun Schmidtke
85 visits